We have all been staring at the sun too long.
Ever since Ethan Muse’s post (almost a year ago!) on the “Miracle of the Sun” at Fatima in 1917, a certain quarter of substack has been unable to let it go. Actually, I don’t think it’d be wrong to say that probably more progress has been made in Sun Miracle-ology in the past year than in the century before that.
If you’re reading this post, I assume you’re already at least generally familiar with this whole business. But if you want the backstory, and if you want to the strongest version of the apologetic argument for the veracity of the Miracle of the Sun as a proof of Catholicism, just read Ethan’s essay.
What is really important, before proceeding, is to nail down what a “sun miracle” is for our purposes. Let’s take Fatima as the gold standard. Here are some representative testimonies from the Cova de Iria that day.
Maria Teresa:
The sky was covered with clouds and it rained much. could not see the sun. Then suddenly, at noon, the clouds drew away and the sun appeared as if it were trembling. It seemed to come down. It began spinning like a fire-wheel in the pagan feasts. It stopped for a few minutes and again started rolling, perhaps in a diameter of more than a meter while we could look at it as though it were the moon. Things all around turned into different colors.
Higino Faria:
At one o’clock the clouds gathered into a very thick and dark form, giving the appearance of an eclipse. At that moment I looked at the multitude and had the impression that it was the day of final judgment. The faces of the people looked thin, long and yellow. Then the dark cloud broke into parts, and through the break we saw the sun shining, spinning in the shape of a wheel of fire. It seemed to approach the earth...
Luis Antonio Vieria:
My friends shout to me: look, look, but at first I only saw clouds drifting by, leaving the sun uncovered. Suddenly, I see an intensely pink rim, surrounding the sun, which resembled a disc of dull silver, as someone once said, while giving me the impression that it was moving from its original position. Diaphanous, vaporous clouds, somewhat purple, somewhat orange, permeated the air. At various points along the horizon, contrasting with the leaden hue of the sky, I also saw pink and yellow spots. The clamor grew louder and louder. This didn’t last seconds: perhaps minutes. As I observed these manifestations, which I never doubted for a moment were due to the Infinite Omnipotence of God, an indescribable impression came over me.
Joseph Frazao:
The sky was covered with clouds but suddenly the clouds opened. The sun seemed to be coming down from the sky and looked like a wheel of fireworks, shooting off all colors of the rainbow.
Jacinto de Almeida Lopes:
The hour approaches, and behold, as if by magic, the rain stops, the sun breaks through the dense, black clouds and reveals itself with its luminous rays, which quickly take on the colors of yellow, red, and green, turning the objects that were under its influence the same colors; and soon loses its brightness and colors—able to be seen with the naked eye without hurting the eyes—and takes on a dizzying rotation, seeming to fall toward the earth. And while observing these wonders, all the people are in loud exclamations. This lasted, at most, about five minutes, then returned to its normal state.
I take these testimonies as broadly representative. A basic pattern emerges:
The clouds part, and the sun emerges.
The sun is found painless to look upon
The sun spins, “like a firewheel,” throwing off sparks.
The spinning sun casts off a succession of colors, “all the colors of the rainbow”
The colors are reflected onto nearby people and objects, usually yellow and pink in particular
Yellow or pink spots are seen on the ground
The sun seems to “fall” to earth or “approach” the earth
About a month after Ethan’s initial post, well-known blogger Scott Alexander weighed in. He called Fatima “the final boss of the paranormal,” admitted that he found the research process disorienting and somewhat frightening, and registered his deep dissatisfaction with the various skeptical explanations on offer. Scott uncovered some interesting things.
Most importantly, that Fatima is not the only sun miracle out there. This is not exactly a secret, but none of these subsidiary miracles are nearly as well-known as the initial showstopper in Portugal.
They include one in a little northern Italian town called Ghiaie in 1946, and a more recent one in Benin City, Nigeria, in 2017, and a couple more obscure ones. These are covered in Scott’s essay.
He noticed that almost all of the really impressive cases happen in cloudy, overcast conditions, which surely cannot be a coincidence. This is so for Ghiaie, Benin City, Necedah, and Lubbock City.
Moreover, while not exact parallels, the reported Fatima phenomena bear more than passing resemblance to the strange activity reported by sungazers. Also see Scott Alexander’s essay for details.
He ended with a rough sketch of his hypothesis:
There is some previously unknown optical illusion that potentially causes the sun to appear to change colors and spin. This phenomenon is rare and inconsistent, and usually appears only after someone has stared at the sun a very long time. This explains why it’s only reported in the wild by a few weird Redditors who stare at the sun on purpose every day.
The appearance of this illusion is somehow modulated by cloud cover. In normal conditions (bright day, no clouds) it’s almost impossible to summon without long periods of sungazing. But when the sun is half-hidden by translucent clouds, the illusion happens much faster. This explains why the Fatima, Ghiaie, Benin City, Necedah, and Lubbock miracles - as well as some of the most impressive Medjugorje cases - all happened just after rain stopped and the clouds were just starting to clear. It also explains why Fatima witnesses say that the sun was “covered in gauze” or “blocked by smoked glass” or “had a diaphanous veil” or “looked like it was seen through a window”. It’s also why, during the most impressive instances of the miracle, people say they can stare at the sun without it being too bright or hurting their eyes.
He admitted that this was only “very tenuous, skeletal draft of a materialist explanation of Fatima,” and that proponents of the miracle need only feel “mildly irritated” rather than “TOTALLY DEVASTATED by IRREFUTABLE debunking.” It is, after all, pretty bold to posit a hitherto totally unknown optical illusion which just happened to occur for the first time in recorded history in the sky over the heads of a crowd eagerly anticipating a miracle.
Well, I still would not say anyone has been totally devastated by an irrefutable debunking, but I think a hypothesis like the one laid out above looks even more plausible now than it did last year.
Sun Miracles Everywhere For Those With Eyes to See
All of the sun miracles that turned up in the initial round of discourse were Catholic, or at least ostensibly Catholic (the Necedah and Heroldsbach miracles being condemned by the church). Ethan and some other Catholics defend a model developed by a priest called Dalleur, that Fatima was carried out by the creation of an anomalous light source in the sky, which was not the actual sun. This model doesn’t really work for some of these other Sun Miracles, and while that add’s some complexity to the hypothesis (you have to posit that these others either weren’t miracles, or God used a different mechanism to prouce the same effect), it doesn’t necessarily wreck it. So the apparently ubiquitous Catholicity of Sun Miracles was certainly a point for the believers. If this is something other than divine action, why does it only happen in contexts that appear to promote this particular religion?
As it turns out, Catholics do not have a monopoly on sun miracles. John Palamas brought to my attention an old European Christian tradition that “the sun dances at Easter” in celebration of Christ’s resurrection.
John has just posted a more thorough write-up here, but I will reproduce the more relevant points:
It is obscure enough that it does not even have a wikipedia page, and yet it appears to have been remarkably widespread before the 20th century. Andrew Carmichael’s Carmina Gadelica recounts a Scotswoman’s sight of the miraculous dancing sun on Easter morn:
The glorious gold-bright sun was rising on the crests of the great hills, and it was changing colour—green, purple, red, blood-red, intense white, and gold-white, like the glory of the God of the elements to the children of men. It was dancing up and down in exultation at the joyous resurrection of the beloved Saviour of victory. To be thus privileged, a person must ascend to the top of the highest hill before sunrise and believe that the God who makes the small blade of grass to grow is the same God who makes the large, massive sun to move.
Suggestive, though we are still missing most of the important Sun Miracle phenomena (no throwing off of sparks, no reflection of color onto onlookers/objects, no noted painlessness). But we do have the sun “dancing” and changing colors.
An Irish Times article from 1998 provides an excerpt from “One John Evans, for example, writing in the 17th century,” who “went up a hill to see the Easter sun appear, and saw it rise, skip, play, dance and turn about like a whale". Impossible to say exactly what he saw, but his vision of the sun “turning like a whale” might plausibly reflect the miraculous “spinning” seen at Fatima and other Sun Miracles.
The tradition is dying out, but it’s not dead entirely. A handful of people discuss their experiences in a facebook thread.
The most telling testimony is this one:
Yes, I remember when I was about 7 years old my aunt and uncle waking me early on easter sunday morning to see the sun dance and it did!! It seems impossible to me now and having thought about it over the years I think it might have been an optical illusion as there was a swirling ground hugging mist over the bog through which the sun was rising red and orange and it seemed to come closer and further back in a sort of dance. Regardless of whether it was supernatural or one of science's anomalies it was quite something and I can see it still in my memory
Well, again, we are missing critical aspects of the phenomena. No succession of colors, no sparks. We do have the sun “coming closer and further back in a sort of dance,” which is certainly reminiscent of the sun “seeming to fall to earth at Fatima and the other sun miracles. And it is surely noteworthy that there was “a swirling ground hugging mist” in the air.
But after all, these are still Catholics in Ireland and Scotland. So perhaps a miracle long-reserved for Easter was repurposed for that day at the Cova.
Now, we leave the Latin west, and cross the European continent to Orthodox Russia:
My first glimpse of a miracle was on assignment from the editorial staff—I was to visit a church before dawn to write a report on Orthodox traditions. I stood there, watched and listened for a while, and then went home. Before bed, I decided to have a cup of tea on the balcony. Just then, the first rays of light appeared over the horizon. But just as the sun rose a few centimeters, it seemed as if someone had covered its blinding disk with a black paper circle. The star refused to accept this: it began spinning at breakneck speed, popping out from behind the circle in all directions, practically wheeling across the sky. Meanwhile, multicolored sparks flew off the sun in a sizable circle, as if it were being “processed” on a lathe. The “mischievous” light lasted only a short time, maybe seven minutes at most. Then the circle disappeared, and the sun majestically crept into the sky…
The following Easter, the miracle repeated itself: just as it was beginning to rise, the sun became hidden behind a dark disk. Only this time, the sun didn’t rotate, but rather darted chaotically in different directions, casting not sparks but multicolored clouds. Each time, as the sun, in its frantic dance of St. Vitus, darted first one way and then the other, pink, blue, yellow, green, purple—all the colors of the rainbow—clouds bounced off it, painting the sky in the most fantastical hues.
If the others were suggestive, this, I think, is unmistakable. Sun spinning - check. Sparks flying off the disc - check. Rainbow colors flying off the sun - check.
The tradition extended to Lutheran Sweden, where Frederika Bremer’s The Rectory of Mora records,
The note about children looking up at the dancing sun through smoked glass recalls people in the town of Alburitel, in Portugal, “darkening bits of glass by exposing them to candle-smoke so that they might watch the sun, with no harm to their eyes,” in anticipation of the 1917 miracle.
I don’t know if the tradition of the Easter sun-dance has any history in Portugal, but considering it appears. in corners of Christendom as far distant as Ireland, Sweden, and Russia, I suspect it does.
Okay, well, if sun miracles are not the private preserve of Catholics, are they at least exclusive to Christianity more broadly?
Apparently not.
In a throwaway comment on an unrelated post a few months back, Sophia in the Shell brought to my attention a highly obscure event known as the “Day of the Crystal Sun.” This took place in Bangkok, Thailand, in 1998. Without going into much detail, a controversial Buddhist sect known as the Dhammakaya had just completed the construction of their massive temple complex.
On September 6 1998, little after 5:00 PM, tens of thousands of devotees were gathered in the open air outside the temple. Someone looked up, and noticed the sun was doing something interesting.
Before we proceed, here’s a selection of testimonies from both Fatima and Dhammakaya, unlabeled and jumbled. Now I admit I have done a little editing, mostly to remove language that seemed a little too archaic (in the case of Fatima) or a little too modern (in the case of Dhammakaya), and thus might give the game away. But otherwise the testimonies are unaltered. See if you can guess which is from which. I have no doubt some of you will get an A, but none of the people I tried it out on got better than a C:
I saw the sun as if it were a clear crystal sphere — bright, yet gentle on the eyes…The crystal sphere then changed colors — becoming bright golden, then bright blue, bright green, bright purple, bright pink, shifting back and forth.
The sun breaks through the dense, black clouds and reveals itself with its luminous rays, which quickly take on the colors of yellow, red, and green, turning the objects that were under its influence the same colors; and soon loses its brightness and colors—able to be seen with the naked eye without hurting the eyes—and takes on a dizzying rotation
The sun started to roll from one place to another place, and changed to blue, yellow, all colors!
When I looked at the sun, I saw…unlike anything I had ever seen before, colors changing back and forth.
I saw the sun shining and spinning very rapidly…I thought my eyes were deceiving me, so I looked down at the ground…When I looked up again…it was spinning.
When I looked at the sun, it… was sparkling…and changing into various colors, beautifully.
Immediately, the sun appeared…and began spinning dizzily. Everything became almost dark, and everyone’s features were yellowish.
A miraculous phenomenon unfolded: a massive cloud obscuring the sun slowly parted, transforming into a spectrum of colors—blue, red, and yellow—allowing the sun to be viewed clearly with the naked eye…in constant motion, spinning rapidly—whirling clockwise at an incredible speed…there was something else I witnessed. In the surrounding area, the people were bathed in a golden light
We…saw the sun, without harm to the eyes. The sun came down, turning on itself, and throwing beams of several colors
Suddenly the sun appeared so that we could look at it as though it were the moon. It began spinning…making us all turn into the colors of the rainbow, even the ground itself
The sun was both clear and its light was cool to the eyes, visible to the naked eye. We then began to see yellow, pink, blue, and other colors of light emanating from the sun.
The sun was spinning and there were clouds of different colors like those of the rainbow.
I saw the sun change colors into different shades—red, pink, yellow, blue, purple—like a rainbow.
The sun rotated around itself, and lights flickered around the sphere…pink light radiated outwards…the colors changed constantly to gold, blue, and orange,
The sun, which had been completely hidden for a moment, left us illuminated by a strange light, with yellow spots visible on the ground.
When she bent down to look at the ground, she was even more surprised to see pink spots on the soil, here and there. Her son asked, “Do you see the stars on the ground?”
Done?
No peeking?
Okay, here’s the answer key:
Major Klanarong Pairipai Rittidet, Dhammakaya
Almeida Lopes, Fatima
Dominic Reis, Fatima
Dr. Tippawan Srichan, Dhammakaya
Sunee Law, Dhammakaya
Dr. Wannana Isaradisaiyakul, Dhammakaya
Father Manuel Pereira da Silva, Fatima
Ampaiporn Sawangdee, Dhammakaya
Maria Teresa Charters, Fatima
Maria do Carmo, Fatima
Anonymous, Dhammakaya
Joaquim Vicente, Fatima
Anonymous, Dhammakaya
Dr. Siriporn Sukhsuttipan, Dhammakaya
Leonor de Avelar e Silva Constancio, Fatima
Kanda Sunthornwittaya, Dhammakaya
I don’t think this can be a coincidence. It is very clear to me that Dhammakaya and Fatima (and all the lesser sun miracles in between) represent, if not the exact same phenomenon, closely related ones.1 All of the detail is present here. We have the clouds parting, the spinning sun, painless to look upon, the sparks, the rainbow succession of colors, the color reflected on the crowd, even very little things like colorful spots on the ground.
And of course, it was overcast that day.
Is this a unique event? Has such a thing ever happened before in the annals of Buddhist history?
Probably.
Brought to my attention by Otto the Renunciant, there is, in Sri Lanka, a Buddhist “stupa” known as Somawathi. Somawathi has something of a local reputation for miracles. In particular, strange rays of light are supposed to play around the top of the stupa in the evenings.
But in 1981, it seems something else happened. According to this article,
At around 2 p.m…the sky turned yellow and the sun appeared dim, resembling the moon. Multi-coloured rays surrounded the stupa, and the white attire of the gathered crowd again appeared yellow. Although the president had planned to unveil the kotha from the ground using a rope system, he chose instead to climb to the top of the stupa via a temporary worker’s staircase after witnessing the unusual spectacle.
This event is much more tentative than Dhammakaya. I have not been able to find any primary, native language sources. Searching for stuff in Sinhala is even more thankless than searching for it in Thai. That said, I am pretty confident this was a real event, because the detail is so specific and familiar. The pale sun, specifically described as “like the moon” (an analogy some Fatima witnesses also reached for), the multi-colored rays, the reflection of the (yellow) color on the crowd. It seems highly unlikely that this obscure account is intentionally patterning itself after Fatima, though of course that cannot be entirely ruled out.
But I feel fairly confident saying this phenomenon has occurred at least twice in the Buddhist world, and probably more times than that.
There are some videos of the “Somawathi rays” on YouTube. I can’t say what the cameraman thinks he’s seeing, but to my eye, they are remarkably similar to Catholic sun miracle videos you also find on YouTube. i suspect the cameramen are seeing the same thing.
Compare Divine Mercy Hills in the Philippines:
And Somawathi:
In a recent discussion with a Catholic, he raised two possible defenses to account for the evident similarities between Dhammakaya and Fatima (which presumably would also apply to the much obscurer Somawathi): one, that the witness statements had been intentionally altered, and two, that demons concocted it as a counterfeit miracle.
I don’t like either of these explanations very much.
The first: I took the argument to be that, perhaps the crowd at the temple that day really did see something remarkable in the sky, but the temple officials massaged the testimony to resemble Fatima more closely. It is true that Dhammakaya has a shady reputation, and its leaders have been caught up in a variety of corruption scandals over the years. And most of the early testimonies are filtered through official temple publications. But the question is not whether the leaders of the Dhammakaya movement are scrupulously honest, but whether they would have any reason to fabricate or “massage” testimony to resemble the Catholic Miracle of the Sun in particular.
Fatima has no meaning to a Buddhist. I would wager most of the people in the crowd that day had never heard of Fatima. If a nefarious monk is going to tamper with eyewitness statements to make them more impressive, he’s much more likely to shape them in accordance with Buddhist expectations rather than Catholic ones.
More problematic still, is that not all of the testimonies come from official publications. A number were posted online by devotees who were there that day. These online testimonies are not notably less Fatima-esque than the ones that were officially disseminated by the temple. There is not much evidence for pro-Fatima shaping on the part of Dhammakaya officials. The only avenue I can see here is to posit that real eyewitnesses who were there that day nevertheless misremembered their own experiences as more Fatima-esque than they had really been, because of the influence of the Temple.
Personally, I don’t have a problem with appealing to the malleability of human memory to cast doubt on miracle testimonies. But in this case, I think that will prove a double-edged sword.
Moreover, my friend not Bob Cobb has personally spoken to three Dhammakay witnesses, who confirm what was seen that day.
As for the demonic hypothesis, it’s really not so different, except that the fabricators and fraudsters are unscrupulous unclean spirits rather than unscrupulous Buddhist monks. I can’t really speak much to it except to say it seems very unmotivated. I’m not Satan,2 but I can’t imagine the best use of his resources is to do a spectacular miracle in a 99% non-Christian country to…convince thousands of those non-Christian to keep being non-Christians. Surely he’d get a better ROI doing this in a country with a large Christian population.
Moreover, the Dhammakaya sun miracle actually happened at least three times (and probably at least five) that year. It happened again in October, and once more in November, on Sundays when large crowds gathered at the Temple.
So you would have to say the demons did it multiple times. Which…maybe, I guess.
God Loves You
If not fraud, if not demons, then what?
A few weeks back I was chatting with Amos Wollen about sun miracles. I said that to me, the almost invariably overcast conditions at these sun miracles speak strongly in favor of some kind of optical illusion. If the explanation is somehow paranormal, whether God, or demons, or mass psychic projections, or something else, there’s no obvious reason why the presence of cloud cover would matter. On the other hand, if, as Scott Alexander’s theory holds, it’s some manner of rare but not that rare optical illusion, the importance of cloud cover might be very important. Perhaps it’s the case that thin (almost invisible, to the point that onlookers perceive no clouds at all in their line of sight) clouds screen the eye from the sun, accounting for the well-recorded painless view and the lack of widespread eye damage.
Amos agreed to a point, but held it strange that, if this is some kind of naturalistically explicable optical illusion, it only seems to happen in religious contexts. I agreed with him that this was the biggest weakness for a skeptical hypothesis. Amos’ idea was that, all of the little features of a Sun Miracle can in principle be accounted for by gazing at the sun through clouds in certain conditions, but —taking a pluralist, Ba’hai inspired view that could accommodate miracles in diverse religious traditions — sometimes God tweaks those conditions just right to produce a truly spectacular miracle over an expectant crowd.
I said to Amos that what would strengthen the skeptical hypothesis further “would be a similar event in some kind of unambiguously non-religious setting like a rock concert or something which, granted, has not happened as far as I’m aware.”
I Can’t Believe It’s Not Mary (Or Buddha)
Over the past couple days, I spent a lot of tedious hours plugging key words like “sun,” “spinning,” “sparks,” “clouds,” “rainbow,” and “disc” into google books to see if I could turn up anyhing interesting.
The first noteworthy thing I found was an account in an old (1882) report on the transit of Venus across the face of the sun:
Some suggestive details here. The limb of the sun “appeared to spin.” There was some “heaving, boiling, and…spinning.” The limb of the sun appeared to consist of “filaments of light,” perhaps recalling the Sun Miracle “sparks” thrown off the spinning firewheel. And of course, we have the presence of clouds.
But it’s only suggestive. No succession of colors, no reflection onto the earth, no note that the sun became painless to look upon.
So I looked a little further, and dug up an astronomy periodical from 1916.
On July 30 of that year, there was an annular eclipse visible from Oceania.
The periodical reproduces article published in The Times of London in September, an extract from the letter of a “Tasmanian lady” who witnessed the eclipse from the town of Swansea. The full article is available on the Times archive, and reproduced via screenshots below:
Here we have all the details. We have the clouds parting on an overcast day, the spinning sun, the off-cast sparks, the “approach” to earth, the succession of colors, the reflection of yellow light onto the crowd, even the little colorful spots reflected onto the earth, attested at both Fatima and Dhammakaya.
I expect supporters of the miracle will point out that neither Fatima nor any of the other Sun Miracles happened during a solar eclipses, which is a pretty important difference. True. But it’s also true that these phenomena are not normally reported during solar eclipses. Whatever produced the effect on this occasion will have to be other than the bare fact of an eclipse, because people look at eclipses pretty often, and they don’t usually see all these things.
I think that what produced this woman’s “miracle” was not just the fact of the eclipse, but the fact that she was staring at the sun through a screen of clouds. If she had stared at the sun the day before from the same spot in similar weather conditions, I think she likely would have seen something very similar. But normally, people don’t stand around and stare at the sun, even on cloudy days. Unless there’s an expectation of a miracle. Or an eclipse.
So if we grant (and I don’t expect everyone will grant it) that this is another example of the Fatima-Dhammakaya phenomenon, what to say about it?
I think all paranormal explanations falter here. You could say God did this one, too. But it’s hard to see why he would want to do a sun miracle for a bunch of random people watching an eclipse in Tasmania, a miracle which nobody apparently took as a miracle.
Demons have an even rougher time, because they have as little motivation to act here as God, and moreover, they couldn’t be aping Fatima because Fatima hadn’t happened yet.3
Any idea that this is a hoax deliberately shaped to look like Fatima fails for the same reason.
I think any hypothesis struggles here besides the one sketched above: that this is a natural, rare, but not that rare phenomenon that appears when the sun is gazed upon through certain cloud conditions.
What, then?
I expect most of the skeptics like myself will remain so, and most of the believers will remain so. I never believed in Sun Miracles, that is, I never believed they were divine actions. But I find them a lot less spooky and mysterious than I did a year ago.
I won’t pretend to give you any mechanism on what is actually happening in people’s eyes and heads when they see this. But it does seem to be the case that it can be seen in contexts that are not Catholic, not “apostolic Christian,” not Christian at all, not even religious at all.
Whatever the precise, actual mechanism is, it seems to be a naturalistic one.
Isn’t it still a huge coincidence that this rare phenomenon happened at the date and time appointed for a miracle? I don’t really think so. This doesn’t actually appear to be that rare. It was common enough to be an Easter tradition all over Europe. People see it at pilgrimage sites all the time, and then they come home and keep seeing it.
Generally speaking, people don’t stare at the sun. It hurts and there’s no real point. And on most days, the conditions probably aren’t conducive to a miracle anyways. But if people stared at the sun more often, I think they’d probably see it pretty often.
So was it a coincidence, sure. But not a huge one, I don’t think.
I don’t think this will be by any means the last word on Sun Miracles. But for the moment, this is where I stand.
You may access my full list of Dhammakaya testimonies here: https://docs.google.com/document/d/155aIbmvRypsuy25X7PIpEipXX_D_eIkRDjc_IVPXJ0Y/edit?usp=sharing
I swear.
Unless St. Michael has a really big mouth and was spouting off about the big miracle planned for next year.







"Amos agreed to a point, but held it strange that, if this is some kind of naturalistically explicable optical illusion, it only seems to happen in religious contexts" hmm, to some extent perhaps but I feel like there are obvious reasons why the phenomena would be more likely to be reported if it occurs in a religious context than if it occurs in a non religious context. It's going to be interpreted with more significance, and the observers are going to have more means and motive to get the word out. Also religious crowds are probably more likely to be on the lookout for anomalies that can be interpreted as spiritually significant. Religious people might also be more prone to like memory effects that cause them to exaggerate their testimonies because they're biased to interpret it as a religious event. Etc etc.
Thanks, great work as always. I came to a similar conclusion as you did - it seems to be a feature of people rarely staring at the sun expecting something like this, possibly requiring some special level of cloud color. I went into more detail near the bottom of https://www.astralcodexten.com/p/waiting-for-the-miracle