Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Mouthy Infidel's avatar

"Amos agreed to a point, but held it strange that, if this is some kind of naturalistically explicable optical illusion, it only seems to happen in religious contexts" hmm, to some extent perhaps but I feel like there are obvious reasons why the phenomena would be more likely to be reported if it occurs in a religious context than if it occurs in a non religious context. It's going to be interpreted with more significance, and the observers are going to have more means and motive to get the word out. Also religious crowds are probably more likely to be on the lookout for anomalies that can be interpreted as spiritually significant. Religious people might also be more prone to like memory effects that cause them to exaggerate their testimonies because they're biased to interpret it as a religious event. Etc etc.

Scott Alexander's avatar

Thanks, great work as always. I came to a similar conclusion as you did - it seems to be a feature of people rarely staring at the sun expecting something like this, possibly requiring some special level of cloud color. I went into more detail near the bottom of https://www.astralcodexten.com/p/waiting-for-the-miracle

44 more comments...

Ready for more?